Skip to content
lyro

Lyro vs Gemini for making songs: an honest comparison (2026)

Updated 30 September 2026

If you want a quick song from a description and you already use Gemini, start there. Since 4 Sep 2026 the Gemini app makes songs with Lyria 3.5, which Google calls its best-sounding music model (Google blog, 4 Sep 2026), in short (about 1 minute) or full (about 2 to 3 minutes) lengths, with limits on how many tracks you can make (Gemini Apps Help, checked 24 Sep 2026). Lyro is a paid studio for the work around a song: it builds on your own vocal or beat, writes lyrics line by line with syllable counts, separates stems, and mixes and masters in the browser. It makes songs on two models under its own names, Lyro High and Lyro Extra, and works on your own audio with its studio tools.

Side by side

LyroGemini
Music modelTwo models from third-party providers, offered under Lyro’s own names: Lyro High, the default and the one for sung Turkish, and Lyro Extra, made for English, German, Spanish, French, Hindi, Japanese, Korean and Portuguese. The default follows one small internal blind test (one rater, seven Turkish-language briefs, 21 Sep 2026)Lyria 3.5, in the Gemini app since 4 Sep 2026
Google blog, 4 Sep 2026
PriceStarter: $14 a month, or $6 a month billed yearly ($72), for 80 credits a month. Creator: $24 a month, or $7 a month billed yearly ($84), for 300 credits a month. Yearly is up to 70% offPart of the Gemini app, with limits on how many tracks you can create. You are told when you reach the limit
Gemini Apps Help, checked 24 Sep 2026
Free planNone. Plans start at $6 a month billed yearly, or $14 month to monthMusic generation is in the Gemini app with usage limits. We have not verified the number of tracks
Gemini Apps Help, checked 24 Sep 2026
Track lengthUp to 3 minutes, set by youShort (about 1 minute) or full (about 2 to 3 minutes)
Gemini Apps Help, checked 24 Sep 2026
Who can use itAnyone aged 16 or over, with a Lyro accountAged 18 or over, signed in with a personal Google Account or a supported work or school account, with Keep Activity on
Gemini Apps Help, checked 24 Sep 2026
ControlsGenre, mood, voice, language, tempo and key, and your own lyrics or lyrics drafted in the lyrics studioSelect or describe a genre, choose vocal or instrumental, and start from templates
Google blog, 4 Sep 2026
DownloadsNot counted or capped. MP3 and FLAC downloads and WAV export from the studio on every plan. A four-way stem splitter on CreatorA video with cover art (MP4) or the audio file alone (MP3)
Gemini Apps Help, checked 24 Sep 2026
Start from your own vocal or beatYes, on every plan, from $14 a month: a beat written around your vocal, or a vocal added to your beat at its tempo and keyThe help page mentions adding files for context. We have not verified whether a vocal or a beat can be used as part of the track
Gemini Apps Help, checked 24 Sep 2026
Mixing, mastering and stemsMultitrack mixer and mastering to a loudness target in the browser, on every plan, using no creditsSee their current plans page
Commercial useCommercial licence on every paid plan, subject to our terms and our model providers’ terms. No promise of copyright protectionSee their current plans page
AI labellingAI-generated tag in every download. Output from Lyro High and Lyro Extra also carries an inaudible watermark added by the model providerEvery track has an embedded digital watermark to help identify it as AI-generated
Gemini Apps Help, checked 24 Sep 2026

Where Gemini is stronger

  • Included in an app you may already have. Song generation is part of the Gemini app, with usage limits (Gemini Apps Help, checked 24 Sep 2026). Lyro has no free plan.
  • A video to share. Gemini lets you download the song as a video with cover art or as an MP3 (Gemini Apps Help, checked 24 Sep 2026).
  • Google’s scale. Lyro is a small new product that uses models from third-party providers.

Where Lyro is different

Lyro is built for the steps before and after a song is generated.

  • Your own vocal or beat. Lyro detects the tempo and key of your upload in the browser, then writes a beat around your vocal or adds a vocal to your beat.
  • Lyrics you shape line by line. The lyrics studio counts syllables per line and marks rhymes, so a verse fits its melody. The same counter is free on its own at the syllable counter.
  • Stems, mixer and mastering. Split a track into vocals, drums, bass and other, rebalance it in a multitrack mixer and master it to a loudness target, all in the browser.
  • Files for elsewhere. MP3, FLAC and WAV from the studio on every plan, stems on Creator, and downloads are never counted. Every paid plan includes a commercial licence under our terms.
  • Two models to choose from. Lyro High, the default and the one for sung Turkish, and Lyro Extra. Work on your own audio runs in Lyro’s studio tools.

Which should you pick

If you wantConsider
A quick song from a description, to listen to or shareGemini, within its usage limits
A vocal on your own beat, or a beat around your own vocalLyro
Stems, a mixer and mastering in one placeLyro: the mixer and mastering on every plan, stems on Creator
Lyrics that fit a melody, counted line by lineLyro’s lyrics studio, or the free syllable counter with either product
A commercial licence stated in the planLyro. We have not verified Google’s terms for generated music, so read them before you release a Gemini track

What this page does not claim

We make no claim about which sounds better: our small blind test did not include Gemini. We also make no claim that Gemini lacks a feature. Where Google’s two pages do not say, the table says “See their current plans page”. Everything about Gemini here was read on Google blog, 4 Sep 2026 and Gemini Apps Help, checked 24 Sep 2026.

Sources

Hear it for yourself.